Overrated
Popular cards rated as fringe or trap. The crowd plays them heavily; our raters think you can do better. Sorted by EDHREC rank ascending, so the most popular contrarian picks float to the top.
Popularity cap
Smaller cap surfaces only the most-popular contrarian picks.
113 cards found · fringe / trap (Brawl) inside EDHREC's top 5,000 · sorted by EDHREC rank ↑
Witch Enchanter
Creature — Human Warlock // Land
Brawl2CmdrF·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·
Snakeskin Veil
Instant
Brawl2CmdrF·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·counters-voltronvoltronplus-one-counters
Hydroelectric Specimen
Creature — Weird // Land
Brawl1Cmdr1·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·flickerblink
Bender's Waterskin
Artifact
Brawl2Cmdr2·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·
Valley Floodcaller
Creature — Otter Wizard
Brawl1Cmdr1·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·spellslingertempocreature-types-matter
Redirect Lightning
Instant — Lesson
Brawl2Cmdr2·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·controlmidrange
Seize the Spoils
Sorcery
Brawl2CmdrT·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·treasurewheelsspellslinger
Secret Rendezvous
Sorcery
BrawlTCmdrT·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·group-hug
Peer into the Abyss
Sorcery
BrawlT→2CmdrT→2·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·millcombo
Tangled Islet
Land — Forest Island
Brawl2Cmdr2·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·
Coveted Jewel
Artifact
BrawlF→2CmdrF→2·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·group-hug
Pristine Talisman
Artifact
BrawlF→2CmdrF→2·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·
Waterlogged Teachings
Instant // Land
Brawl2CmdrF·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·modal-dfc-matters
Arid Archway
Land — Desert
Brawl2Cmdr2·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·lands-matterself-millgraveyard-matters
Umbral Collar Zealot
Creature — Human Cleric
Brawl1Cmdr1·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·aristocratssacrificeself-mill
Matzalantli, the Great Door
Legendary Artifact // Legendary Land
Brawl2→1Cmdr2→1·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·
Sacred Peaks
Land — Mountain Plains
Brawl2Cmdr2·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·
Sunlit Marsh
Land — Plains Swamp
Brawl2Cmdr2·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·
Weftstalker Ardent
Creature — Drix Artificer
Brawl1Cmdr1·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·aristocratsartifact-matterstokens-go-wide
Shared Roots
Sorcery — Lesson
Brawl2CmdrT·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·ramp-big-manalands-matter
Metalwork Colossus
Artifact Creature — Construct
BrawlF→1CmdrF→1·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·artifact-matterscombo
Walk-In Closet
//Enchantment — Room // Enchantment — Room
BrawlF→1CmdrF→1·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·lands-matter
Secret Tunnel
Land — Cave
BrawlF→2CmdrT·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·tokens-go-wide
Bulk Up
Instant
Brawl2Cmdr2·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·aggroburnvoltron
Spectral Sailor
Creature — Spirit Pirate
Brawl2Cmdr2·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·tempocontrolspirit
Many Partings
Sorcery
Brawl1Cmdr2·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·lifegainfood
Conduit Pylons
Land — Desert
BrawlF→2CmdrF→2·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·self-millgraveyard-matterslands-matter
The Eternity Elevator
Legendary Artifact — Spacecraft
Brawl2→1Cmdr2→1·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·ramp-big-manacombotokens-go-wide
Tree of Perdition
Creature — Plant
Brawl2→1Cmdr2→1·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·comboaristocrats
Crash Through
Sorcery
BrawlFCmdrT·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·aggrotempotokens-go-wide
Krenko's Command
Sorcery
BrawlFCmdrT·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·tokens-go-widearistocrats
Party Thrasher
Creature — Lizard Wizard
Brawl1Cmdr1·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·spellslinger
Funeral Room
//Enchantment — Room // Enchantment — Room
Brawl2→1Cmdr2→1·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·reanimator
Origin of Metalbending
Instant — Lesson
Brawl2Cmdr2·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·plus-one-counters
Cycle of Renewal
Instant — Lesson
Brawl2Cmdr2·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·ramp-big-manalands-matter
Season of Weaving
Sorcery
Brawl2→1Cmdr2→1·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·spellslingercombocontrol
Infectious Inquiry
Sorcery
Brawl2Cmdr2·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·spellslingercombo
Echoing Deeps
Land — Cave
Brawl1Cmdr1·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·lands-mattergraveyard-mattersramp-big-mana
Consuming Corruption
Instant
Brawl2Cmdr2·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·midrangecontrol
Chameleon, Master of Disguise
Legendary Creature — Human Shapeshifter Villain
Brawl2→1Cmdr2→1·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·flickerwheelsself-mill
Prologue to Phyresis
Instant
Brawl2CmdrT·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·infect-toxicspellslinger
Reckless Handling
Sorcery
BrawlFCmdrT·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·comboartifact-matters
Bloodsoaked Insight
Sorcery // Land
BrawlT→FCmdrT→F·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·
Abraded Bluffs
Land — Desert
Brawl2Cmdr2·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·burnlifegain
Bite Down
Instant
BrawlTCmdrT·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·
Hell to Pay
Sorcery
BrawlT→FCmdrT→F·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·treasureburnmidrange
Singularity Rupture
Sorcery
BrawlFCmdrF·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·controlmill
Circle of Power
Sorcery
Brawl1Cmdr1·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·spellslingerwizardscombo
Charred Foyer
//Enchantment — Room // Enchantment — Room
BrawlT→1CmdrT→1·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·
The Cabbage Merchant
Legendary Creature — Human Citizen
BrawlF→2CmdrF→2·Comp BrawllegalCommanderlegal·foodlifegaingroup-hug